A $1 million traditional IRA is not a $1 million inheritance.
The account may show seven figures, but most or all of that money has never been taxed. The tax bill does not disappear when the owner dies. It follows the account to the beneficiary, often with a much shorter payment schedule.
That schedule changed under the SECURE Act. Before 2020, many non-spouse beneficiaries could stretch distributions over their life expectancy. Most adult children who inherit now must empty the account within ten years.
A traditional IRA can still be worth leaving behind. It should be judged by its after-tax value to the person receiving it, rather than by the balance on the statement.
Retirement Accounts Do Not Receive the Usual Basis Reset
An heir who receives appreciated stock in a taxable account generally receives a new cost basis tied to the asset’s fair market value at death. If the stock is sold shortly afterward for roughly that value, little or no capital gain may remain.IRS Publication 559 explains how inherited property is generally valued for basis purposes.
A traditional IRA works differently. Its untaxed balance is generally income in respect of a decedent. When the beneficiary takes distributions, the taxable portion is usually treated as ordinary income. There is no comparable reset that erases the deferred income tax.
This difference can be substantial. A parent may own a traditional IRA, a Roth IRA and a taxable brokerage account with the same market value, yet each can be worth something different to an heir after taxes.
Roth accounts are usually more favorable because qualified withdrawals are tax-free. They are still subject to post-death distribution rules, however, and earnings can be taxable when the original Roth had not satisfied its five-year holding period.The IRS outlines the tax treatment of inherited traditional and Roth IRAs in its guidance for survivors.
The Ten-Year Rule Has Two Versions
Most non-spouse beneficiaries who do not qualify for a special exception must empty an inherited retirement account by December 31 of the year containing the tenth anniversary of the owner’s death. The required withdrawals during that period depend partly on whether the owner died before or after the required beginning date for RMDs.
The exceptions are fairly narrow. An “eligible designated beneficiary” can include the surviving spouse, the owner’s minor child, someone who is disabled or chronically ill, or an individual no more than ten years younger than the owner.The IRS lists these beneficiaries and the distribution options available to them. An owner’s adult child usually does not qualify merely because they are the owner’s child.
If the owner died before that date, the beneficiary generally does not have to take annual distributions during years one through nine. The entire balance simply must be gone by the end of year ten.
If the owner died after RMDs had begun, the result is different. Annual distributions generally must continue during the ten-year period, and the remaining balance must still be distributed by the deadline. The final IRS regulations retain both the annual distribution requirement and the ten-year deadline.
That second rule is easy to miss. “Empty it within ten years” sounds flexible. It is less flexible when a minimum amount must come out every year along the way.
An inherited Roth IRA is generally treated as though the owner died before the required beginning date because Roth IRA owners do not take lifetime RMDs. Most non-spouse beneficiaries can therefore leave the account intact during the first nine years, but it must generally be emptied in year ten.
Employer plans add another layer. The document governing a 401(k), 403(b) or other qualified plan determines which distribution options it offers.The IRS advises beneficiaries of qualified plans to obtain those options from the plan administrator. An heir should not assume an old employer plan will operate exactly like an inherited IRA.
Ten Years Can Still Produce a Bad Tax Result
Having ten years does not tell an heir how much to withdraw in each one.
Suppose an adult child inherits a $1 million traditional IRA while earning $250,000 a year. Assume the owner died before the required beginning date, so no annual withdrawal is required. If the account grows at 6% and nothing is taken out, it could approach $1.8 million by the end of ten years. Taking that balance in the final year would stack a large amount of ordinary income on top of salary and other income.
Dividing the original balance into ten equal withdrawals is not automatically the answer either. Income may change during the period. The beneficiary could retire, sell a business, move to a different state or have a year with unusually large deductions. The account should be distributed around the heir’s actual tax picture, subject to any annual RMDs, rather than by a mechanical ten-year schedule.
The owner’s tax rate matters too. Paying tax through planned withdrawals or Roth conversions during the owner’s lifetime can make sense when the owner is in a lower bracket than the likely beneficiaries. It can be a poor trade when the owner pays a higher rate merely to spare an heir who will pay less.
The relevant comparison is the owner’s current tax rate and the beneficiary’s likely rates during the inherited account’s distribution window.
A Spouse Has More Options
A surviving spouse who is the sole beneficiary can generally keep the account as an inherited IRA or elect to treat it as their own. Those choices can lead to different distribution dates and different access rules.IRS beneficiary guidance explains the additional options available to a surviving spouse.
Age can change the better answer. A spouse younger than 59½ who may need the money might keep the inherited account for a time because distributions received as a beneficiary are generally exempt from the 10% early-distribution tax. Rolling the account immediately into the spouse’s own IRA could remove that particular exception for later withdrawals before 59½.
Keeping the inherited account is not always the answer. “Roll it over” should simply wait until cash-flow needs, age and RMD timing have been reviewed.
The Beneficiary May Matter More Than the Account
Leaving pretax retirement money to a high-earning adult child can create a compressed tax problem. Leaving it to a surviving spouse may provide much more flexibility. Naming a qualified charity can be especially efficient because the charity can generally receive the retirement dollars without the income tax an individual beneficiary would owe.
That can support a deliberate division: retirement assets to charity and taxable or Roth assets to family. It should be coordinated across the beneficiary forms, will, trust and charitable documents so the percentages still produce the intended result as account values change.
Trusts require particular care. A trust may be useful when the goal is to control access or protect a beneficiary, but merely naming a trust does not guarantee favorable retirement-account treatment.IRS rules require a trust to satisfy specific conditions before its beneficiaries can be treated as designated beneficiaries. An older trust drafted around the former stretch rules deserves another look.
Review the Plan While There Is Still Time to Change It
The most useful inheritance planning happens before anyone inherits the account.
Estimate the after-tax value of each asset to each beneficiary. Compare lifetime withdrawals and Roth conversions under several tax-rate assumptions. Confirm whether charitable gifts should come from pretax accounts. Then check the actual beneficiary forms, including contingent beneficiaries, instead of assuming the will controls every account.
Retirement accounts can still transfer meaningful wealth. The SECURE Act removed much of the long deferral period that once made them unusually attractive inheritances. The tax now arrives faster, which can change the right beneficiary for the account.
This article is for informational purposes only and is not tax, legal or investment advice.